The Poughkeepsie Tapes (2007)

Director:

John Erick Dowdle

Writers:

Drew Dowdle (story)
John Erick Dowdle (writer)

Release Date:

2009 (USA)

Genre:

Crime | Horror | Thriller

Tagline:

The Terror is Real

Plot:

When hundreds of videotapes showing torture, murder and dismemberment are found in an abandoned house...

Plot Keywords:

Videotape | Torture | Serial Killer | Murder | Dismemberment

Cast

Stacy Chbosky	...	Cheryl Dempsey
Ben Messmer	...	Ed
Samantha Robson	...	Samantha
Ivar Brogger	...	Leonard Schway
Lou George	...	Felton Lewis
Amy Lyndon	...	Alice Endrisart
Michael Lawson	...	Simon Alray
Ron Harper	...	Mike Moakes
Kim Kenny	...	Pam Frears
rest of cast listed alphabetically:
Iris Bahr	...	Psychiatrist
Scott Beehner	...	Jason Ribling
Adarsha Benjamin	...	Victim 2
Kelli Bielema	...	Jane Gerber
Linda Bisesti	...	Sandra Willets
Lisa Black	...	Victoria Dempsey
Marissa Blanchard	...	Girl Scout 1
Bill Bookston	...	James Foley
William Bookston	...	James Foley
Oto Brezina	...	Dr. Farhad Mansourian
Jules Bruff	...	Blinker
Paul Buxton	...	Walter Kunkler
Todd Cahoon	...	Ted Bundy
Blaire Chandler	...	Cynthia Gorman
Larry Clarke	...	Edgar Cummings
Donna Cooper	...	Prostitute 2
Bruce Cronander	...	Harvey Scroggs
Meredith Cross	...	Jeanette Anderson
Henry Dittman	...	Frank Anderson
Bobby Eskandari	...	Dr. Arnold Montufar (as Bobby Alexander)
Dennis Garber	...	Joseph Danvers
Chip Godwin	...	Hank Foley
Jennifer Griswold	...	Jennifer Griswold
David Haack	...	Tim Surrey
Tom Hauser	...	News Anchor
Keisuke Hoashi	...	Dai Loung
Sean Huze	...	Hector Gomez (scenes deleted)
Michael Hyland	...	Profiling Student 1 (as Mike Hyland)
David James	...	Tim Surrey
Ceciley Jenkins	...	Traci Looner
Zale Kessler	...	Frederick Miller
Morgan Lariah	...	Profiling Student 2
Fiona Lincke	...	Reporter
Bobbi Sue Luther	...	Josephine
Sierra Marcoux	...	Jennifer Gorman
James Mathers	...	Bernard Golinko
Paulah May	...	Investigator
Leah McLean	...	News Anchor
Tracy Miller	...	TV Reporter
Naveen	...	Dr. Arjay Vintopeej
Philip Newby	...	Irwin Griffard (as Phil Newby)
Bruno Oliver	...	Joel Gorman
Steven M. Porter	...	Albert Cromley
Adrian Roberts	...	Warden
Brad Satin	...	Himself
Brooke Sikkema	...	Girl Scout 2
Heather Snell	...	Jennifer Henshaw
Joann Socrates	...	Victim #1
Erin Stutland	...	Victim 1
Beth Tapper	...	Karen Tyler
David Wilcox	...	Jacob Polinski
Mark McClain Wilson	...	Mark Rongitch

MPAA:

Rated R for sadistic violence and torture, including terror and graphic descriptions.

Runtime:

86 min

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Color:

Color

Certification:

USA:R

Filming Locations:

Los Angeles, California, USA

Company:

Brothers Dowdle Productions

Certainly not perfect, but effective nonetheless.

"The Poughkeepsie Tapes" is a tough film to review. Much like any recent horror film, there are going to be people who love it and people who hate. Reading some of the recent reviews here and on other prominent horror sites, one would think this film is as sloppy and as terrible as "Ax 'Em" or "Dark Fields." In fact, though this film has a plethora of problems, I believe it is an effective, creepy, and thought-provoking little film.

It is presented as a documentary. Basically, a serial killer has been terrorizing the community of Poughkeepsie, New York for years. Cops are baffled by the cleverness of the killer. He is even able to frame a police officer, who is executed for the crimes. When they discover the home of the serial killer, police and FBI find hundreds of VHS tapes, each detailing the crimes of this vicious killer. We are shown footage of these tapes, interwoven with interviews of police officers, family members of victims, and even a victim herself to get a perspective of the killer and his crimes. Some of the footage is downright creepy and disturbing, including the murder of a young child and torture of several victims. The mask the killer wears is also quite creepy.

One of the main problems with the film is in presentation. We are suppose to be viewing "real" footage of the killer and his crimes, but can't help to notice the convenient "suspenseful" background music that plays during each clip. Did the killer go in and edit and add music to each of his tapes? The killer's identity remains a mystery throughout the whole film and it is a stretch to ask viewers to believe the he was able to get away with some of the stuff he did (framing a police officer). The acting by some is rather hokey, but I can't decide if it was meant to be that way because is is suppose to be "real" people being interviewed, or if these people are just bad actors.

Despite the flaws, "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" does some things extremely well, mainly making the viewer uncomfortable. The killer is pretty brazen, and it is horrifying to think that, yes, there ARE people out there like that. Like the film says, there are anywhere from 25-40 active serial killers working at any given time in the United States. The black and white footage of the "crimes" is pretty effective and provides some great tension. There is also one scene where the killer is walking on all fours toward a victim with his creepy mask on that gave me chills. Though the ending is unsatisfying, it almost couldn't have ended any other way.

Overall, I have seen MUCH worse. Those dismissing this as nothing but brainless torture porn obviously have short attention spans or just weren't paying all that close attention to it. The film is constructed and edited very well (despite the flaws I mentioned above) and the story is actually pretty solid. I can tell a lot of thought went into this film. It could have been better, but that can be said about any film. Go in with an open mind and watch this with the lights off at night. I am willing to be you will be looking behind you and checking to see if your doors are locked more than once.

FrightMeter Grade: B