Home
search
more | tips
IMDb > Nada (2001) > IMDb user comments

IMDb user comments for
Nada (2001) More at IMDb Pro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 9 comments in total 

8 out of 8 people found the following comment useful :-
The postman only rings once, 19 May 2006
7/10
Author: jotix100 from New York

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

Carla, a young woman living alone in Havana, has a thankless job in a local post office. She is the one responsible for canceling the stamps in all the letters that are deposited in that branch. She also has an knack for selecting different letters that "speak" to her. When she opens them, she transforms the text. Where there was despair, she writes a hopeful message; where there is loneliness, she is a solace for the one that will receive it. Even for a television personality she is instrumental in changing one of the letters that criticize him into a loving poem that when he reads it on his program, is an instant success.

This young woman has won the visa lottery to go to the United States, where her parents are now living. At the beginning of the story, all she wants to do is get away from the monotony of her lonely life and go join her family in Miami. Fate intervenes in the form of Cesar, one of the letter carriers. He is young and begins to see that in spite of Carla's problems at work and in her personal life, she is worth pursuing.

There are different interpretations about the Cuban realities in the film. One can see certain things in which some of the country's problems are seen by Carla, her co-workers, and even by her nosy neighbor. Carla wants to help others, but she hardly can help herself. When the new manager arrives, she sees right through her employee that something funny is happening. At the end, Carla receives the exit permit and we watch her take a taxi to the airport, but we realize she is not going anywhere.

The film is a light comedy directed by Juan Carlos Cremata Maberti, who also co-wrote it and contributed to the editing of the film. Shot in black and white, it incorporates certain color elements to emphasize what's happening in a particular scene. Thus, we see the yellow pencil used by Carla, as well as the many colors of her Tiffany lamp, the gold fish in the glass jar, the yellow taxi, the butterfly and the rainbow at the end of the film while the background is always black and white.

Thais Valdes plays Carla with stoic determination. She doesn't express much, making this enigmatic woman into somebody that is playing magic behind what she writes in the letters. Daisy Granados, a veteran actress of the Cuban cinema appears as Cunda, a manager from hell. Nacho Lugo is seen as Cesar and the delightful Paula Ali has some funny moments as the office spy.

This film shows a new director in the Cuban cinema. Juan Carlos Cremata Maberti shows he has an innovative way for telling his story and has gathered an interesting team to work on it.

Was the above comment useful to you?

7 out of 7 people found the following comment useful :-
Nothing, 26 April 2003
10/10
Author: Rai from San Francisco, CA

While the film-maker kept insisting this film is "nothing" I found it a brilliant piece of art. Filmed in black and white, but with certain items, emblems, and images in vibrant color, this film speaks volumes through it's manipulation of the art of film to say "nothing".

It is pure farce, poignant drama, and slapstick comedy all rolled into a love poem to Cuba.

While nothing in Nada should be taken too seriously, it never once panders to its audience with simple cheap laughs. Well, ok, some characters are certainly intended as pure caricatures, which others have rightly identified as in the style of "commedia d'ell arte". This is part of the film's joy. This is not to say that the film doesn't have some poignant moments.

Nada is the story of a bored and lonely postal worker in Havana named Carla who decides to play God with the letters that pass through her hands. Through a twist in fate, a spilled bit of coffee, Carla happens upon the world of the letter writers, those whose mail she mindlessly stamps "priority" on a daily basis. Suddenly she is confronted with the sadness and loneliness of not just her own life, but the world outside. For a lark she decides to re-write the letter ruined by the coffee spill, but instead of re-writing it as it had been written, she alters it.

In one of it's more brilliant and moving moments; using truly mesmerizing camera work, we listen as Carla re-writes a letter to a woman bent on ending her life. The woman's long flower patterned dress is in color. We follow this woman into an old empty house; following at a distance, as she finds her way to the bath. Carla has written her about the need to live life with a passion, and not to live simply a long life. We watch as the woman disrobes, and then slips into the bath tub, disappearing from the screen, the camera moves in slowly towards the tub. This deliberate and slow movement heightens the melodrama unfolding. Has she just climbed into an empty tub? Is this her way of ending an un-lived life? I won't spoil this moment here, you should see it for yourself.

The amazing thing about this moment, is that, as different as it is from much of the rest of the film, it doesn't feel out of place. Nor does the moment as we listen to Carla's re-write of a letter from a daughter to her father. We watch this man, thinking about the letter he has just read, as he moves slowly to the sea wall, the camera first facing him, and then slowly moving up over, and then behind him to look out to the sea with him. We don't linger, but the point has been made, for during this high tracking shot over him we have been listening to Carla's voice tell us of the love this daughter holds for her father, even while she hasn't seen him for years.

But again, Nada never takes itself seriously, it isn't about anything (please read a wry smile here). And soon we are always back to some silly moment with the nosy bureaucrats in the Post Office, or the noisome, neighbor. And finally Nada fulfills itself as a love story between Carla and Cesar, a fellow postal worker she enlists in her efforts to change the world around her.

Juan Carlos Cremata Malberti indicated at the SFIFF where I saw it, that Nada is the first of a trilogy he plans to make. For a first feature that can be both subtle at one moment, and hit you with a sledge-hammer the next I only hope the wait is very short.

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
A fun Havana ride if you like poetic slapstick, 24 April 2006
9/10
Author: amerh from Washington, DC

Opinions seem to vary greatly about this film. Some viewers seem to like it, find it real cute, compare it to Amelie, enjoy the shifts in style and tone. Others seem to loathe it, find it derivative, decry the exaggerated acting, disjointed style and too simple story, and feel they have wasted 90 minutes watching it. The opinions run all over the map, as the grades and critics reviews show. Some love it, many hate it.

I don't understand the latter group. This is exactly the kind of film I enjoy, in the same style as the movies of Richard Lester and Maurizio Nichetti (the early ones like Ratataplan). Start with a rather original story: a lonely post office employee who rewrites letters in her spare time. Amelie came out at the same time, and features a young girl who also tries to change others lives, but in many ways Nada is more fun and less smug. The disjointed style and abrupt shifts of tone kept me entertained. Here is a director who loves to play around. The slapstick scenes were exaggerated, as they should be, the romantic scenes funny and touching, and two sections showing how the letters affect their recipients were, in my opinion, successfully poetic.

Malberti shows promising talent with interesting predominately black and white camera work, which sometimes imitates the style of silent comedy, from Chaplin features to Keystone Cops. The quirky editing, overhead shots, fanciful touches, and series of funny supporting characters all contribute to the movie's charm. Thais Valdez is really charming, at the same time a fun cute tomboy and a mature weary lover. She is a real find.

If you like your films sober, intellectual and serious pass this one up. If you are ready for a wild mixture of bureaucratic satire, introspective social drama, slapstick comedy, cute love story, Havana travelogue and some poetic moments then jump along... It's a real fun ride!

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
Have the kind of juice that make your head spin, 23 April 2003
9/10
Author: Len Zayas (hispano@zayas.ws)

Nada Más is as complex as the Cuban people itself. The little pieces of daily life activities get complicated by bore and danger. This movie have the kind of juice that make your head spin. The characters are well elaborated and portrayed in the caricaturing way of the silent film era. The viewer feel bouncing between hate, sympathy and despise for everyone involved in the plot and depending of the moment. This movie can be anything but boring. I recommend it.

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following comment useful :-
Anti-bureaucratic film in style of Richard Lester. Great fun!, 24 January 2006
10/10
Author: lnp3 from United States

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

Nada+ "Nada+" (Nothing More) is the latest in a series of Cuban films such as "Strawberries and Chocolate" and "The Waiting List" that satirize bureaucracy. Such films are the most effective rebuttal to claims in both the conservative and liberal press that Cuba is a totalitarian dungeon. Indeed, "Nada+" is irrefutable evidence that the main challenge to bureaucratic stupidity and oppression comes from the government itself, since without government funding such films would never see the light of day.

What better symbol of bureaucracy is there than the post office, which serves as the setting for "Nada+." Carla Perez (Thäis Valdés) is a young, beautiful and supremely bored clerk who spends each day rubberstamping incoming mail while listening to music on a portable radio at her desk.

To relieve the tedium, she has begun to steal letters in order to get into the lives of the writers, who function as characters in soap operas for her. Taking things one step further, she begins to write back letters to the sender in the name of the original recipient. But her letters are more compassionate, more loving and more sensitive than anything that they would be capable of, with an impact that is often highly dramatic.

One of the unsuspecting recipients is a Cuban equivalent of Doctor Phil, who has an afternoon talk show proffering advice to the unhappy, but he himself is far more tormented than any of his callers. He throws a tantrum one day at Carla's office when no letters are found in his mailbox, accusing the workers of stealing his mail. In this instance, however, Carla had nothing to do with it. Taking pity on him, she decides to write him a fan letter assuming the identity of one of his viewers. So deeply moved is he by her words that he confesses to his audience that he has been living a lie, tears off his toupee and attempts to strangle himself with a microphone cord!

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 4 people found the following comment useful :-
Nice effort, 6 March 2004
Author: raulpu50 from Miami

While the story is quite trivial, the flamboyant filmmaking style makes up for it. It is definetely a step forward for the Cuban Film Industry. The film alternates almost chaplinesque moments with some poetic scenes. The film was shot in

Black and white but certain elements in the shots are colored. The

cinematography and editing are quite competent. Some of the characters are a

little exagerated and I didn't find that the tone was right in those moments. But overall: Nice.

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
C yourself differently, 6 April 2007
7/10
Author: Lee Eisenberg (eisenberg.lee@gmail.com) from Portland, Oregon, USA

Since we in the United States don't often get to see Cuban movies*, it's refreshing to see "Nada". It portrays a woman named Carla Perez working in a Havana post office opening people's letters and rewriting them so as to make them more comprehensible and even poetic...much to the chagrin of her supervisors (who, if combined, would act like and resemble the Wicked Witch of the West). But this might set in motion a new path for Carla's relationships with people.

Aside from the main plot, the movie gives us a look at the lives of ordinary Cubans, far from the famous images of Fidel Castro and his cabinet. The black-and-white cinematography with a few objects colored gives one - well, gives me, at least - the sense of people feeling somewhat depressed in a world without guaranteed electricity, but trying as hard as possible to pull through.

One thing that I noticed in the movie is that all the characters had names beginning with C (Carla, Cunda, Concha, etc). I wonder what was up with that. It may have had something to do with Cuba beginning with C (along with Cuba's trading partner China).

Overall, worth seeing.

*It seems like this might also be the case in Cuba; I think that most of the movies which they get to see in Cuba come from - where else? - the United States.

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
Nada has mucho, 4 October 2002
7/10
Author: rockmen43 from Canada

Although this has been called an over-the-top story some of the writing is done very passionately. I particularly enjoyed the letter being read while a women was taking a bath. I wish some of this passion could be present in more North American movies. Thais Valdes is an excellent actress and hopefully she can get more roles in movies like this in the near future. The satire with the bureaucracy in the mail office is dead on.

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 6 people found the following comment useful :-
Rien de tout, 17 December 2003
1/10
Author: openthebox

I caught this Cuban film at at an arthouse film club. It was shown shortly after the magisterial 1935 Silly Symphony cartoon where the Isle of Symphony is reconciled with the Isle of Jazz. What with the recently deceased Ruben Gonzalez piped through speakers in this old cinema-ballroom and a Cuban flag hanging from peeling stucco rocaille motifs, the scene was set for a riproaring celebration of engaged filmmaking and synchronised hissing at the idiocies of Helms-Burton. But then the film started. And the cinema's peeling paint gradually became more interesting than the shoddy mess on-screen.

The storyline of Nada Mas promises much. Carla is a bored envelope-stamper at a Cuban post office. Her only escape from an altogether humdrum existence is to purloin letters and rewrite them, transforming basic interpersonal grunts into Brontëan outbursts of breathless emotion. Cue numerous shots of photogenic Cubans gushing with joy, grief, pity, terror and the like.

The problem is that the simplicity of the narrative is marred by endless excursions into film-school artiness, latino caricature, Marx brothers slapstick and even - during a particularly underwhelming editing trick - the celluloid scratching of a schoolkid defacement onto a character's face.

Unidimensional characters abound. Cunda, the boss at the post office, is a humourless dominatrix-nosferatu. Her boss-eyed accomplice, Concha, variously points fingers, eavesdrops and screeches. Cesar, the metalhead dolt and romantic interest, reveals hidden writing talent when Carla departs for Miami. A chase scene (in oh-so-hilarious fast-forward) is thrown in for good measure. All this would be fine in a Mortadello and Filemon comic strip, but in a black-and-white zero-FX flick with highbrow pretensions, ahem.

Nada Mas attempts to straddle the stile somewhere between the 'quirky-heroine-matchmakes-strangers' of Amelie and the 'poetry-as-great-redeemer' theme of Il Postino. Like Amelie, its protagonist is an eccentric single white female who combats impending spinsterdom by trying to bring magic into the lives of strangers. And like Il Postino, the film does not flinch from sustained recitals of poetry and a postman on a bicycle takes a romantic lead. Unfortunately, Nada Mas fails to capture the lushness and transcendence of either film.

There are two things that might merit watching this film in a late-night TV stupor. The first is the opening overhead shot of Carla on a checker-tiled floor, which cuts to the crossword puzzle she is working on. The second is to see Nada Mas as a cautionary example: our post Buena Vista Social Club obsession with Cuban artistic output can often blinker us into accepting any dross that features a bongo on the soundtrack. This film should not have merited a global release - films such as Waiting List and Guantanamera cover similar thematic territory far more successfully.

Was the above comment useful to you?

Add another comment

Related Links

Plot summary Ratings Awards
External reviews Main details Your user comments
Your vote history