 | Kevin Spirtas | ... | Celebrity Contestant (5 episodes, 2000) |
| Rachel Blakely | ... | Celebrity Contestant (4 episodes, 2000) |
| Jon Huertas | ... | Celebrity Contestant (4 episodes, 2000) |
| David Orth | ... | Celebrity Contestant (4 episodes, 2000) |
| Kona Carmack | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Tyler Christopher | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Michael Dietz | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Lisa Robin Kelly | ... | Celebrity Contestant / ... (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Jordan Ladd | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Andrew Lauer | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Brandy Ledford | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Judson Mills | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Shanna Moakler | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Michael Newman | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Kelly Packard | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Marissa Tait | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Jacob Young | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Arianne Zucker | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Charissa Chamorro | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 2000) |
| Omar Gooding | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 2000) |
| Amy Hunter | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 2000) |
| Don Jeffcoat | ... | Himself - Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 2000) |
| Roma Maffia | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 2000) |
| Kathleen McClellan | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 2000) |
| Marissa Ribisi | ... | Celebrity Contestant (3 episodes, 2000) |
| Shaun Baker | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Jason Brooks | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Leah Lail | ... | Herself (2 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Kala'i Miller | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Seth Peterson | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999-2000) |
| Michael Bergin | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999) |
| A.J. Buckley | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999) |
| Natalia Cigliuti | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999) |
| James DeBello | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999) |
| Adrienne Frantz | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999) |
| Stacy Kamano | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999) |
| Alison Sweeney | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 1999) |
| Victor Alfieri | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Nadia Bjorlin | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Angelle Brooks | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Mick Cain | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Alex Désert | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Danielle Fishel | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Soleil Moon Frye | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Ricky Paull Goldin | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Schae Harrison | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Shar Jackson | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Tsianina Joelson | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Bryce Johnson | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Sean Kanan | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Mario López | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Chris William Martin | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Marnette Patterson | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Alisa Reyes | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Lisa Rieffel | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Michael Saucedo | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Kavan Smith | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Jeff Stearns | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
| Priscilla Taylor | ... | Celebrity Contestant (2 episodes, 2000) |
