Home
search
more | tips
IMDb > Una breve vacanza (1973) > IMDb user comments

IMDb user comments for
Una breve vacanza (1973) More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 9 comments in total 

10 out of 10 people found the following comment useful :-
Sad and beautiful., 5 March 2005
10/10
Author: mdibner from Durham, NC

This is an amazingly beautiful film. The story of a woman of little means and a horrendous family life who learns much about the world in a sanatorium in the Italian alps. It gives her a brief vacation from a hard life. And understanding. And hope. Truly wonderful. Florinda Bolkan is a great actress ... emoting without emotion. This movie has many levels of plot and story rolled into a single, seemingly simple story. There are many levels of relationships in the movie. Of particular interest is the set of relationships formed between patients from the upper class, the 'paying' patients and those who are in the sanatorium paid for by the national health. The juxtapositions between have and have not, happy and sad, sick and healthy, doctor and patient, hardworking and lazy and many others form the basis of what we see as Clara's learning process and set of life dilemmas.

Hard to find but worth it. Belongs on the top 250 list....but not enough people have seen it to vote.

Was the above comment useful to you?

9 out of 11 people found the following comment useful :-
Awakening of a woman., 5 June 2004
Author: Gerald A. DeLuca (italiangerry@gmail.com) from United States

Vittorio De Sica collaborated again on this excellent film with screenwriter Cesare Zavattini, as he had in the postwar "Shoe Shine," "The Bicycle Thief," Umberto D," and their 60s French film "A Young World." They have fashioned, from a story by Rodolfo Sonego, a realistic and at times romantic drama about an Italian housewife (Florinda Bolkan in an amazing performance), living in a Milan suburb and married to a crass husband (Renato Salvatori) who treats her like a pack animal.

She supports the husband, unemployed because of an accident as well as her three sons and several in-laws, by working in a grim factory worse than that in Petri's "The Working Class Goes to Heaven" or Rossellini's "Europa '51."

She collapses from exhaustion and TB and is sent at company expense for "una breve vacanza" at a sanatorium in the Dolomites. Here she experiences a major change and awakening, not merely physical and emotional (as in a tender relationship with a machinist) but a profound radical change in which she examines for the first time her fundamental nature as a human being and as a woman. She can never be the same after she returns home.

Italian class and sex attitudes are perceptively analyzed here, and there is un unforgettable characterization by Adriana Asti as a foul-mouthed yet compassionate woman in the last days of a terminal illness. (Remember her in Bertolucci's "Before the Revolution"?)

I find it ironic that though this great "feminist" movie was written and directed by men, it is more effective in that regard in ways that its contemporary "Swept Away," made by a woman, is not.

Was the above comment useful to you?

5 out of 5 people found the following comment useful :-
One woman's monumental toil for love, duty and survival, 3 July 2002
10/10
Author: jwelch666 from Eagle River, Alaska

This is one of my all time top ten favorite movies. I find it frustrating that it has never been released on VHS or DVD. It looks at the personal struggle of a woman in a no win situation and her serendipitous but temporary solace - and the ultimate and inevitable return to her life struggle. It is so personal it is universal. Unbelievable it has not been more widely available.

Was the above comment useful to you?

5 out of 6 people found the following comment useful :-
One of De Sica's best- and that's saying a lot, 28 August 2003
10/10
Author: Mick (Sees All) from New York

This is not an adaptation of THE MAGIC MOUNTAIN. The only thing the two works have in common is that they both take place in a sanitarium. It's the story of a woman who has a horrible life of hard work and no appreciation. She takes ill and is sent by the government to a sanitarium where she thrives. Getting sick is the most wonderful thing that has ever happened to her. I found this film extremely moving. Florinda Bolkan gives a great performance of subtle realism. A BRIEF VACATION is a brilliant film, right up there with De Sica's best, and it came late in his career. He directed only one more film afterward. I saw this film a couple of times in the 70s. I still think about scenes from it.

Was the above comment useful to you?

4 out of 5 people found the following comment useful :-
one of the best movies ever made, 20 December 2005
10/10
Author: wedraughon from United States

This is the story of a woman given a respite from her grim life as a devoted wife and mother. She takes her illness in stride and goes off to the mountains to a sanatorium for a cure. While there, she meets people she would never have met otherwise and has time to experience a life other than one of drudgery and selfless devotion. She is even given a chance of escape/salvation. Will she take it? Ah, but that would be a spoiler!

This superb movie shows that realism can be moving and gripping. This woman's plight, her decency and her quiet heroism make for one of the best motion pictures ever made. If it could be released on video or DVD, I'm sure it would do well. Let's hope the owner of the rights to this movie soon figures this out.

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 4 people found the following comment useful :-
Once again, proof that De Sica was a great and under-appreciated director, 28 February 2007
9/10
Author: planktonrules from Bradenton, Florida

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

I have never understood why Vittorio De Sica is not thought of as one of our greatest directors. I have heard and read gobs of praise for Hitchcock, Kurosawa, Bergman, Fellini, Godard and many others but have rarely noticed similar accolades for De Sica--yet he was responsible for many of the greatest films I have seen. Aside from his super-famous film, THE BICYCLE THIEF, few have seen or discussed his masterpieces such as MIRACLE IN MILAN, UMBERTO D. or THE CHILDREN ARE WATCHING US (my personal favorite)--yet these and many more of his films are among the greatest ever made. He was one of the directors responsible for creating a style of film ("Neo-realism") but here in the States, you'd never know this unless you are a crazed film fan (like myself). The trademark of these Neo-realist films are non-actors performing in very ordinary situations that usually are ignored in big-budget films. Despite what you may think, these films are definitely NOT dull and grab the viewer emotionally because he truly learn to love and care about the characters in the films. Generally, these small-budget films are super-true to life and the acting and writing are phenomenal.

I made this little rant to set the stage for A BRIEF VACATION, as it is a late Neo-realistic film by De Sica. Once again, the characters are very simple Italian folk--the sort you'd almost never see featured in a film. In addition, the actors are not easily recognizable to the audience. As a result, you truly grow to care about the central character and root for her. But, also because it's a Neo-realistic film, the ending is true to the character instead of having a Hollywood-style ending where everything works out fine! The plot of the film involves a very over-worked and completely unappreciated working mother. She is the sole provider for a home with three small children, a lazy and obnoxious brother-in-law, a meddlesome mother-in-law and a temporarily disabled husband. When she has trouble keeping up at work, she goes to the local clinic and find out she has TB and needs to go on an extended rest--paid for by the state health care system. However, her selfish family insist she's fine and want her to stay on the job because they are just awful people who want her to stay and take care of their needs. Unfortunately, this nice lady is so nice, she has a hard time standing up for herself. But, when the problem is too much, she does finally go to the sanitarium despite their petty protests.

At the sanitarium, her life changes. Instead of being so quiet and shy, she slowly comes out of her shell and makes many friends. She even attracts the attentions of a handsome younger man who desperately wants to marry her and take her away from her rotten home life. Seeing the lady blossom is amazing but true to the spirit of Neo-realism, the film ends on a less than fairy tale-like fashion but one very true to the characters.

This is an excellent film with exceptional acting and direction. Some might find the subject matter a tad mundane, but believe me, it's worth some patience.

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
Interruption in the Alps, 27 March 2009
Author: Chris_Middlebrow from Austin, Texas

A Brief Vacation is a quiet Italian drama from 1973, directed by Vittorio De Sica who was acclaimed for The Bicycle Thief a quarter century earlier.

Florinda Bolkan plays a female factory worker in Milan whose husband's employment has been sidelined for the time being by injury. Thus she is the breadwinner for a family that includes children, a mother-in-law, and a brother-in-law. She already is close to collapse from the wear and tear of her job, and the fatigue of the train commutes to and from it. Family members prove extremely selfish, increasing the stress and burden.

But she has a spot on her lung, a patch of tuberculosis, the equivalent of a golden war wound in combat. There is insurance for health care, and a guarantee of a continued flow of salary during leave for recuperation. The movie makes a welcome shift to a sanatorium in the Alps, where the only demands are to get plenty of sleep and rest and be pampered by the doctors, nurses, and other staffers. This is the brief vacation from which the movie title derives, and brings a chance to meet new friends and a pause to reflect on life. De Sica via the interruption produces another winner.

It might be added that it was a long wait to see the movie again. A Brief Vacation was never released on VHS, and consequently it took three full decades, and the advent of the DVD era, to bring the film to home viewers. Take advantage.

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
Who Knew TB Could Be Such A Blessing?, 14 June 2008
7/10
Author: ferbs54 from United States

Those viewers who are feeling a little down about their own particular life situation may be a bit cheered when they see what Clara Mataro's daily grind is like, in Vittorio de Sica's 1973 offering "A Brief Vacation." The sole breadwinner in her family, living in a dingy, cramped apartment on the outskirts of Milan with her loutish husband, thuggish brother-in-law, waspishly senile mother-in-law and three young sons, her torturous job at a rubber factory is just another element in her daily hell. No wonder that when the National Health clinic forces her to go to a sanatorium in the Italian Alps to cure her incipient TB, Clara views this as the titular brief vacation. (If only the U.S. had a health care system like this!) Away from her usual troubles and surrounded by new friends, Clara inevitably blossoms, and that metamorphosis is wonderful to see. Florinda Bolkan, who had greatly impressed me in such marvelous gialli as "Lizard in a Woman's Skin" and "Don't Torture a Duckling," is superb here as Clara, especially when the prospect of a possible love affair at the sanatorium arises. Clara's fellow patients are a very interesting bunch; de Sica, the old neorealist master, directs winningly yet unobtrusively; son Manuel de Sica's theme song "Stay" is lush and superromantic; and the snowy backdrop of the Alpine countryside is often quite spectacular. So, does the film give poor Clara the reward of a happy ending? I would never dream of telling, but those who have seen such earlier de Sica classics as "The Bicycle Thief" and "Umberto D" might be able to guess. Clara Mataro is a remarkably well-drawn character, and my feeling is that most viewers will be very happy that they have spent a few brief hours with her....

Was the above comment useful to you?

0 out of 7 people found the following comment useful :-
no credit for book i believe movie was written from, 15 January 2001
Author: aidas_g from Hockessin, DE, USA

It seems to me that this movie was an adaptation of Thomas Mann " The Magic Mountain " but i see no credit. I just couldn't help but notice the strong comparisons between the book/movie however although i did prefer the book, the movie should be recommended....if you can find it!!.

Was the above comment useful to you?

Add another comment

Related Links

Plot summary Ratings Awards
External reviews Plot keywords Main details
Your user comments Your vote history