IMDb > The Poor Little Rich Girl (1917) > IMDb user comments
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 7 comments in total 

6 out of 6 people found the following comment useful :-
One of Mary's most enjoyable movies, 23 January 2005
7/10
Author: wmorrow59 from Westchester County, NY

This delightful film marked a turning point in the career of Mary Pickford, the first time in adulthood that she played a little girl. The illusion was enhanced with specially scaled sets and props that made Mary look smaller, and also by casting unusually tall actors as the "grown-ups," but it wouldn't have worked if Mary herself hadn't been such a gifted performer in her own right. She is remarkably convincing as 11 year-old Gwendolyn. It's notable that when Mary (who was 24 when this film was made) plays scenes opposite Maxine Elliott (who was 12 at the time), the illusion is not spoiled. The great success of THE POOR LITTLE RICH GIRL at the box office ensured that Mary Pickford would be playing little girls well into her 30s, despite occasional attempts to demonstrate more versatility, eventually causing her to consider the role something of a curse, but in any event the film holds up nicely today: it's interesting, suspenseful, and funny, with odd touches of surrealism during the extended dream sequence that forms the climax.

Mary's Gwendolyn is certainly a sympathetic protagonist. The story paints a vivid picture of the girl's loneliness and her desperation to receive some attention from her high society parents, but she's no sad sack-- she's a spirited kid bursting with vitality, though she's surrounded by servants who devote themselves to stifling her energy. She's sheltered but no snob, and much of the havoc she creates comes when she invites some of the scruffier neighborhood kids inside to play. The comic high point is a mud fight that takes place in the green house of Gwendolyn's home. (Oddly enough, Mary Pickford revealed in later years that director Maurice Tourneur was opposed to the inclusion of this sequence and had to be persuaded to film it.) The mud fight is great fun, but for me the movie's real highlight comes when Gwendolyn, ill and delirious, has a bizarre dream that offers metaphors for her life and the people she's known. For instance, her mean-spirited governess, described earlier as a "snake in the grass," actually appears as such in the dream, while another character is shown to be "two-faced." I won't reveal any more of the imagery for anyone who might see this film, except to note that the dream sequence alone is worth the price of admission.

P.S. I happened to see THE POOR LITTLE RICH GIRL at a recent screening at the Museum of the City of New York, where locally-made movies are occasionally screened. Viewers interested in New York City history may be interested to learn that this film includes location scenes of Mary taking a ride along Riverside Drive as well as some brief shots of Wall Street. My fellow New Yorkers got a big laugh at one point when Gwendolyn's father contemplates selling his mansion for $15,000!

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
Thoughtful & Entertaining, 3 July 2002
Author: Snow Leopard from Ohio

With a good combination of a thoughtful story and entertaining scenes, this Mary Pickford vehicle works well and is pleasant to watch. Pickford is surprisingly convincing in portraying the "Poor Little Rich Girl", a character who is supposed to be less than half the age of the actress - some creative set design and Pickford's own charm and enthusiasm make it work.

Much of the film simply describes the world of young Gwen (Pickford), neglected by her parents and bullied by most of the servants, and thus lonely and unhappy despite living amidst material abundance. It picks up the pace as it moves along, and the best part is the dream sequence near the end - it is quite amusing, and also does a nice job of summarizing the themes of the story. The minor characters are worked into the story well, and a couple of them are entertaining in their own right.

When you put Pickford and her winsome style in a story like this, chances are good that it's going to be enjoyable to watch, and this is not an exception. It's a nice little film, and worth the trouble to find.

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
Charming portrayal of "the poor little rich girl", 2 August 2000
Author: ladymarylasenby (fuzzyria@aol.com) from Columbus, Ohio

The movie is wonderful in its innocence. Mary Pickford plays Gwendolyn, the unhappy child of a rich father, whose only care is the Stock Market, and a society-obsessed mother, who does not consider her child before the daily rounds of calls she pays. When Gwen is forced to tell of her loneliness, children of her mother's friends do not turn out to be successful playmates either. Miss Pickford excellently portrays the ten-year-old Gwen, though she was at an age of some 24 years when she made this picture. A wonderful family film!

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following comment useful :-
America's Sweetheart, 2 April 2005
7/10
Author: Cineanalyst

In addition to typecasting Mary Pickford as playing child characters, this role established her as America's Sweetheart. The 24-year-old Pickford plays an 11-year-old rich girl, who's neglected by her parents and is raised by nasty housekeepers and several personal schoolmarms. The only playmate she's allowed is a bore. Of course, every viewer sympathizes with the character's predicament, and Pickford gets the most out of that. The mud fight and tantrum scenes add some amusement between the more gushy moments and the great dream sequence.

Much of the credit here also needs to go to the screenwriter Frances Marion. Besides being a woman in a male-dominated business, she was one of the first scenarists to have creative control over productions. Like another female screenwriter, Anita Loos, Marion helped introduce the role of intertitles in silent film (as opposed to the tableau style of title cards only to introduce scenes). Both women also sometimes demonstrated their authorship with self-referential winks; Marion's 'Armarilly of Clothes-Line Alley' and Loos' 'Wild and Woolly' are two examples--where the authors expose their constructions with one intertitle.

Pickford does well to overcome the weirdness of an adult playing the role of a child. Moreover, the setting of a mansion, in addition to large props and tall actors accentuate Pickford's natural smallness, but more needed to be done about her adult figure. Director Maurice Tourneur and the film-making crew add appropriate, non-intrusive style to this sweet photoplay, providing Pickford with the most important vehicle of her career.

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
A Study Of Neglect, 26 December 2001
8/10
Author: Craig Smith (csmith13@woh.rr.com) from Toledo, Ohio

Like so many of the silents, there is a powerful message here about family and the importance of family. Here is a little girl with everything money can buy except the time of her parents. They are so busy with making money and the social circuit they have no time for their little girl (Mary Pickford). As is also the case with so many silents, the cue cards make sure that we understand the points the makers want made. And as has been the case in so many other silents, the movie makes its points very well and did not need the extra cue cards to make them. Having said that, this is a very good movie. Early films could do a very good job of telling a story and making a statement. This one does indeed do both.

Was the above comment useful to you?

Wonderful Mary, 4 February 2009
8/10
Author: kidboots from Australia

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

This is an exquisite film and a wonderful introduction to Mary Pickford if you are unfamiliar with her films. "The Poor Little Rich Girl" was originally done on the stage in 1913 with Viola Dana playing Gwendolyn. Even though Mary had played young girls in all her feature films, this was the first time she had ever portrayed a child (except the Famous Players Lasky film "A Good Little Devil" - a role Mary had originated on the stage in 1913 for David Belasco). She could have no better director than Maurice Tourneur.

Tourneur, a French director, specialised in fantasy films ( "The Blue Bird", "Prunella", "Treasure Island", "The Wishing Ring" etc) and he bought style and imagination to them. In the dream sequence, which so brilliantly explores the mind of a child, Gwen brings the nick names she hears to life. Her father is "made of money", the servants are "big ears", "two faced thing" and "snake in the grass". She goes to the land where they "burn candles at both ends". This is so magically done by Tourneur, who certainly expanded the film from how I could imagine the play. The sets and actors also seem to be on a larger scale to make Mary appear even tinier than she was (I think she was 4' 10").

Gwen (Mary Pickford) is a poor little rich girl, who's father is too busy making money and her mother has too many social obligations to give her the attention and affection she needs. The servants who are introduced by the title - "Servants by name - Masters by disposition" - are seen as bullying tyrants. All except "Silly Ass" - the only one Gwen has a strong affection for.

One afternoon she has fun - she invites the organ grinder and a street boy in and she and Mr. Piper (the man who fixes the pipes) have a dance. The street kids feel sorry for Gwen and call her the poor little rich girl. Another day one of her mother's friends brings her own little girl over to play but Susie May (Maxine Elliott Hicks) is not nice, is a sneak and a tattle tale and gets Gwen into trouble. Gwen gets her own back when she makes Susie sit on a plate of cakes. Gwen's mother then forces her to give up her best lace dress but Gwen refuses and throws all her clothes out of the window - the neighbourhood kids then take them. To punish her, her father forces her to dress in boys clothes but she secretly likes it and joins a boy's street gang.

The underlying theme is that Gwen is searching for happiness. The film takes a very dramatic turn when Gwen is given an overdose of sleeping medicine by two servants who want the evening off to visit the theater. Mr. Piper is the person who finds her and in her delirium, her parents realise how much they have neglected her when she almost dies. Her father, who has lost most of his money in the Stock Market crash realises that his family will be happier, living a simpler life in the country.

Highly Recommended.

Was the above comment useful to you?

Burning the Candle at Both Ends, 27 April 2008
10/10
Author: wesconnorsehny from Earth

Wealthy ten-year-old Mary Pickford (as Gwen) lives in a beautiful mansion; she has everything she needs, except love. She must make an appointment to see her father (Charles Wellesley), who spends his time wheeling and dealing; and, she barely gets an opportunity to see her mother (Madlaine Traverse), who is busily attending to social duties. Her parents do not have time to spend with lonely Ms. Pickford; and, she is left in the care of unloving servants.

A lot of studio trickery helps to make Pickford believable as the fun-loving, independent and lonely little Gwendolyn; her age is not at all vague, as her 11th birthday is celebrated during the running time. You'll notice the large sets, and tall actors (standing on telephone books, no doubt) right away. Yet, finally, it's Pickford who pulls off the ruse. When she sits down for her tutoring, in close-up, Pickford makes the character a fully believable individual. The effort to make Pickford appear small adds to the film's surreal whimsicality.

Importantly, "The Poor Little Rich Girl" is the first of Pickford's adult portrayals of little girls. Her relative youth, and lack of "affected" mannerisms, is an early strength; she is fresh, and convincing. Later on, Pickford's portrayals suffered, as she employed stock muggings, pouts, and grimaces (to be fair, these were responsive to moviegoers increasing demand she remain in the "little girl" roles). Subsequently, the Pickford mannerisms were more cloyingly adopted by Shirley Temple, and others; for example, note how closely Pickford resembles Ms. Temple after she dons a boy's hat and clothes.

Director Maurice Tourneur and set designer Ben Carré help create the extraordinary, whimsical world "Gwen" inhabits. There are some "special effect" sequences, ending with a drug-induced delirium. Therein, Pickford dreams about the day's people and events; and, finally, she meets the beckoning figure of death, who invites: "Here, in the forest, dark and deep, I offer you, eternal sleep…" Maxine Elliott Hicks and Herbert Prior are among the more notable supporting players. Frequent Pickford writer Frances Marion does a fantastic job bringing story details together; she, Pickford, Mr. Tourneur, and Mr. Carré certainly created a monster.

********** The Poor Little Rich Girl (3/5/17) Maurice Tourneur ~ Mary Pickford, Maxine Elliott Hicks, Herbert Prior

Was the above comment useful to you?

Add another comment

Related Links

Plot summary Ratings Awards
External reviews Plot keywords Main details
Your user comments Your vote history