| Academy Awards, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1999 | Nominated | Oscar |
Best Actor in a Leading Role for: American History X (1998) |
| 1997 | Nominated | Oscar |
Best Actor in a Supporting Role for: Primal Fear (1996) |
| Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1999 | Nominated | Saturn Award |
Best Actor for: American History X (1998) |
| 1997 | Nominated | Saturn Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: Primal Fear (1996) |
| BAFTA Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1997 | Nominated | BAFTA Film Award |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role for: Primal Fear (1996) |
| Blockbuster Entertainment Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2000 | Nominated | Blockbuster Entertainment Award |
Favorite Action Team for: Fight Club (1999) Shared with: Brad Pitt |
| Boston Society of Film Critics Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1996 | Won | BSFC Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996) Also for Primal Fear (1996) and Everyone Says I Love You (1996). |
| Chicago Film Critics Association Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1999 | Nominated | CFCA Award |
Best Actor for: American History X (1998) |
| 1997 | Won | CFCA Award |
Most Promising Actor for: Primal Fear (1996) Also for The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996) and Everyone Says I Love You (1996). |
| Chlotrudis Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1999 | Nominated | Chlotrudis Award |
Best Actor for: American History X (1998) |
| Florida Film Critics Circle Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1997 | Won | FFCC Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: Primal Fear (1996) Also for Everyone Says I Love You (1996) and The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996). |
| Golden Globes, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1997 | Won | Golden Globe |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Motion Picture for: Primal Fear (1996) |
| Gotham Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2006 | - | Tribute Award | |
| Independent Spirit Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2007 | Nominated | Independent Spirit Award |
Best Male Lead for: The Painted Veil (2006) |
| Kansas City Film Critics Circle Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1997 | Won | KCFCC Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: Primal Fear (1996) |
| Los Angeles Film Critics Association Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1996 | Won | LAFCA Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: Everyone Says I Love You (1996) Also for Primal Fear (1996) and The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996). |
| MTV Movie Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2000 | Nominated | MTV Movie Award |
Best Fight for: Fight Club (1999) For fighting against himself. |
| 1997 | Nominated | MTV Movie Award |
Best Villain for: Primal Fear (1996) |
| National Board of Review, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1996 | Won | NBR Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: Everyone Says I Love You (1996) |
| Online Film Critics Society Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2000 | Nominated | OFCS Award |
Best Actor for: Fight Club (1999) |
| 1999 | Nominated | OFCS Award |
Best Actor for: American History X (1998) |
| San Diego Film Critics Society Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2006 | Won | Special Award |
for: The Illusionist (2006) Also for The Painted Veil (2006) and Down in the Valley (2005). For the body of work. |
| Sant Jordi Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2004 | Won | Sant Jordi |
Best Foreign Actor (Mejor Actor Extranjero) for: 25th Hour (2002) |
| Satellite Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2005 | Nominated | Satellite Award |
Outstanding Actor in a Supporting Role, Drama for: Kingdom of Heaven (2005) |
| 2003 | Nominated | Golden Satellite Award |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture, Drama for: 25th Hour (2002) |
| 2001 | Nominated | Golden Satellite Award |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture, Comedy or Musical for: Keeping the Faith (2000) |
| 1999 | Won | Golden Satellite Award |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Drama for: American History X (1998) |
| Society of Texas Film Critics Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1996 | Won | STFC Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996) Also for Primal Fear (1996). |
| Southeastern Film Critics Association Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1999 | Won | SEFCA Award |
Best Actor for: American History X (1998) Also for his performance in Rounders (1998). |
| 1997 | Won | SEFCA Award |
Best Supporting Actor for: Primal Fear (1996) Also for The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996) and Everyone Says I Love You (1996). |
| Street Film Festival, Milan | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2000 | Won | Street Award |
Best Feature Film for: Keeping the Faith (2000) |