| Academy Awards, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1957 | Nominated | Oscar |
Best Actor in a Supporting Role for: Friendly Persuasion (1956) |
| Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1987 | Nominated | Saturn Award |
Best Actor for: Psycho III (1986) |
| Cannes Film Festival | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1961 | Won | Best Actor |
for: Goodbye Again (1961) |
| Edgar Allan Poe Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1974 | Won | Edgar |
Best Motion Picture for: The Last of Sheila (1973) Shared with: Stephen Sondheim |
| Golden Globes, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1957 | Won | Golden Globe |
Most Promising Newcomer - Male Together with John Kerr and Paul Newman. |
| San Sebastián International Film Festival | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1991 | - | Donostia Lifetime Achievement Award | |
| Walk of Fame | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| unknown | - | Star on the Walk of Fame |
Motion Picture At 6801 Hollywood Blvd. |