| Academy Awards, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1956 | Won | Oscar |
Best Actor in a Leading Role for: Marty (1955) |
| BAFTA Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1956 | Won | BAFTA Film Award |
Best Foreign Actor for: Marty (1955) USA. |
| Daytime Emmy Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1999 | Nominated | Daytime Emmy |
Outstanding Performer in an Animated Program for: "All Dogs Go to Heaven: The Series" (1996) |
| Emmy Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1980 | Nominated | Emmy |
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or a Special for: All Quiet on the Western Front (1979) (TV) |
| 1963 | Nominated | Emmy |
Outstanding Continued Performance by an Actor in a Series (Lead) for: "McHale's Navy" (1962) |
| Golden Boot Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1985 | - | Golden Boot | |
| Golden Globes, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2008 | Nominated | Golden Globe |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Mini-Series or a Motion Picture Made for Television for: A Grandpa for Christmas (2007) (TV) |
| 1956 | Won | Golden Globe |
Best Motion Picture Actor - Drama for: Marty (1955) |
| Independent Spirit Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1989 | Nominated | Independent Spirit Award |
Best Supporting Male for: Spike of Bensonhurst (1988) |
| Laurel Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1961 | 2nd place | Golden Laurel |
Top Action Performance for: Pay or Die (1960) |
| Locarno International Film Festival | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1959 | Won | Prize |
Best Actor for: The Rabbit Trap (1959) |
| National Board of Review, USA | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1955 | Won | NBR Award |
Best Actor for: Marty (1955) |
| New York Film Critics Circle Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1955 | Won | NYFCC Award |
Best Actor for: Marty (1955) |
| Razzie Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1982 | Nominated | Razzie Award |
Worst Supporting Actor for: Deadly Blessing (1981) |
| San Luis Obispo International Film Festival | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 1997 | - | King Vidor Memorial Award | |
| TV Land Awards | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| 2005 | Nominated | TV Land Award |
Favorite Airborne Character(s) for: "Airwolf" (1984) |
| Walk of Fame | |||
| Year | Result | Award | Category/Recipient(s) |
| unknown | - | Star on the Walk of Fame |
Motion Picture At 6324 Hollywood Blvd. |