ENRON: The Smartest Guys in the Room
Reviewed by Harvey S. Karten
Magnolia Pictures
Grade: B+
Directed by: Alex Gibney
Written by:Alex Gibney, book "The Smartest Guys in the Room"
by Bethany McLean, Peter Elkind
Screened at: Park Ave., NYC, 3/15/05
See this film and you're likely to add quite a few hits to websites
like scholar Louis Proyect's http://marxmail.org. "Enron: The
Smartest Guys in the Room," is a doc based on the best-selling
non-fiction book, "The Smartest Guys in the Room," by Bethany
McLean, who appears in the film, and by Peter Elkind. What
transpires therein is so jaw-dropping with villains so audacious
that you've got to wonder whether this is something Hollywood
made up as a psychological thriller, or even a horror story.
You don't necessarily have to be a leftist to be disgusted with
the way the top executives of Enron, the seventh largest
corporation in the U.S., acted. Its bankruptcy was brought about
by a flagrant cooking of the books, e.g. by claiming as profit
what was merely expected or, more accurately hoped for. This
got its stock price soaring. The bubble, which brought the price
down from its high of $90 per share to a buck twenty wiped out
the life's savings of thousands of Enron workers who were
encouraged to put all their 401(k) income exclusively into
Enron–something that no reputable executive of any company
could or should recommend.
According to Gibney's script, narrated nicely by Peter Coyote,
the principal cause of the disastrous down-slide of the stock
price is that the honchos–namely the CEO, the president, and
the Chief Financial Officer–cashed in their holdings, making off
with about a billion dollar in cash. The thousands of workers
with savings in the 401(k) had their accounts frozen to prevent
them from getting out while they could still save their
retirements.
Somehow Alex Gibney was able to dig up a boatload of videos
that could conceivably be used to convict the indicted leaders
whose trials are coming up this year. These, together a striking
sound track of original music by Matt Hauser, even a Simpsons
cartoon that shows the family heading up in a roller coaster
shouting "we're gonna be rich," then plummeting down swiftly
into "the poorhouse" make "Enron: The Smartest Guy in the
Room" no mere talking-heads documentary. On the contrary,
this is an entertaining picture throughout with humorous
moments balancing a story about the sort of scandal that can
arise when government stays out of the regulation business and
allows private corporations to manipulate prices.
Among the extras judicially added to the doc to both increase its
entertainment value and add painlessly to our knowledge is a
black-and-white tape of the famous Milgram experiment of the
early sixties. A mock scientist, clad in a white coat, tells a
participant to give a man seated several feet away (in reality an
actor) increasing jolts of electricity whenever he answers a
question incorrectly. When the participant objects, the scientist
urges him to continue. (In reality, no electricity is passed
through the corridor, the actor merely feigning pain with
increasing yelps.) Fifty percent of participants ignored the cries
of the seated man and obeyed the scientist. The moral: If a
person in authority tells you to do something that you find
loathsome, there's a fifty-fifty chance that you'll go ahead and
listen to the authority figure. This explains why so many
thousands of Enron employees dutifully put their entire life's
savings into company stock.
Enron was formed in 1985 when Houston Natural Gas merged
with InterNorth, a natural gas company based in Omaha. Enron
became the proud owners of 37,500 miles pipe. Two years
later, Enron discovers that oil traders in Valhalla, New York,
have been diverting company funds to their personal accounts.
Five years later, Jeff Skilling, who gets a considerable amount
of movie time, joins Enron and becomes its chief operating
officer, leading the company to build a power plant in India for
$2,8 billion. The plant is a flop, the infrastructure now a
wasteland. Notwithstanding the debacle, Jeffrey Skilling–who at
one point sheds his nerdy appearance by getting Lasik eye
surgery and plunging into extreme sports–is made chief
executive while one Ken Lay remains as chairman. When
Enron moves into the broadband business, it declares $53
million in earnings though not a cent was made in profits.
Enron could not have indulged in its cook-the-books scheme
without the help of outsiders, notably from the allegedly
reputable accounting firm, Arthur Anderson which found nothing
particularly wrong in auditing the Enron books.
Cooking the books and making huge profits for executives who
bailed out while the stock price was still high was not all.
Somehow Enron was so devious that it appears able to do
nothing ethically correct. In California, the company convinced
the Republican governor in power before the hapless Gray
Davis to deregulate the electricity industry in that state. The
Enron traders, joking about the citizens about to be shafted,
ordered the power turned off every other day in order to justify a
huge increase in the price of electricity while claiming that there
was an unfortunate shortage. President Bush does nothing,
stating his typical mantra, "Trust in the force, the magic of the
marketplace."
Director Alex Gibney believes that "the relationship of big
business and politics will be intimate as long as politicians need
increasingly large sums of money to run for office." He answers
those who believe that the market will ultimately correct all
imbalances and that supply and demand will moderate prices is
thus: "The world of investment banking and big business is a
world unto itself in which a few powerful people wheel and deal
out of the public idea....Enron and other energy companies all
got together to game the California market."
While the audience at a critics' screening was polite,
presumably awed by the doc, we hear that "Enron" sold out the
theater at the Southwest Film Festival, got a standing ovation
and a catcall of boos, hisses and disgust, the audience yelling
and cursing at the screen after learning how a privileged few
bankrupted the country's seventh largest corporation. The doc
was offered at the 2005 Sundance Film Festival as well.
"Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room," mimics the over-the-
top gestures of Michael Moore in his "Fahrenheit 9/11" only at
times, when it offers up the excerpt from a Simpson's cartoon
and hones in literally on a gambling casino when discussing the
ways that the company played with the stockholders' money.
Not Rated. 110 minutes © 2005 by Harvey Karten
harveycritic@cs.com
========== X-RAMR-ID: 39670 X-Language: en X-RT-ReviewID: 1380495 X-RT-TitleID: 1144540 X-RT-SourceID: 570 X-RT-AuthorID: 1123 X-RT-RatingText: B+
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews