ICE PRINCESS
Reviewed by Harvey S. Karten
Walt Disney Pictures
Grade: B
Directed by: Tim Fywell
Written by: Hadley Davis, story by Meg Cabot, Hadley Davis
Cast: Michelle Trachtenberg, Kim Cattrall, Joan Cusack,
Hayden Panettiere, Trevor Blumas, Connie Ray, Kirsten Olson,
Jocelyn Lai, Paul Sun-Hyng Lee, Michelle Kwan
Screened at: Loews E-Walk, NYC, 3/19/05
Harvard University's head honcho, Lawrence Summers, created
a firestorm recently when he announced that women for the
most part are not interested in the sciences. As you watch Brit
director Tim Fywell unfold Hadley Davis and Meg Cabot's story,
"Ice Princess," you at first see the error of Mr. Summers' ways.
By the conclusion, however, you find an argument in his favor.
How so? Just look at the story...
Casey Carlyle (Michelle Trachtenberg) anchors the production
about a young, gifted woman of seventeen who is both athletic
and intellectual. She has a conflict. Her mother, Mrs. Caryle
(Joan Cusack), teaches in a local Connecticut college and is
quite aware that her daughter is a physics geek with straight A's
in a subject in which everyone I know was lucky to get C's. She
has a chance to use her brain to get a full scholarship to
Harvard, but her mother's dream is not Casey's. The
personable, otherwise malleable Casey, is as excellent a figure
skater as she is a budding physicist and wants to postpone her
physics ambitions to train for the Olympics to be held in 2006.
This conflict provides most of the tension in this G-rated movie,
which has a targeted audience of girls between the ages of, say,
ten to eighteen.
Despite the presumed audience for "Ice Princess," Fywell's
feature, however formulaic, can find a paying crowd of people of
any age and both genders, largely because the acting is so
good and even more, because the characters are painted in
shades of gray rather than black or white. No one in the story is
all bad, and though there are no villains, each character is
flawed.
Casey's problem is that she expends too much effort dealing
with her conflict. Though she's about to graduate from high
school, she's still a mama's girl, always on the verge of giving
up her dream simply because her mother insists that there's but
an eight-year shelf life for figure skaters. Mrs. Carlyle's
weakness is that while she recognizes and applauds her
daughter's accomplishments in science, she is so deaf to
Casey's own wishes that she does not attend the young
woman's training sessions and seems intent on ignoring
Casey's performance in an all-important competition. Tina
Harwood (Kim Cattrall), who is Casey's coach and a good one
at that who insists that her students fall in line at the rink at 5:30
each morning, is at an opposite pole from Mrs. Carlyle. She
pushes her own daughter, Gen (Hayden Panettiere), to practice
compulsively on the rink, deaf to hints that the girl wants to be
just a regular teen eager to chuck skating altogether. For her
part Gen is at first hostile to Casey as both are training for the
same sport but over the course of the story learns to appreciate
her rival's talents and to become her best friend.
Most of us in the audience are presumably out of touch with the
competitive world of ice skating, thinking that the ice is meant
only for the use of sportsmen especially from Canada who enjoy
pushing a puck along the field and getting into fights with their
rivals. We not only become attuned to this world but see quite a
few examples of the sport in action, as competitive skaters like
Korean-American Tiffany (Jocelyn Lai), whose father (Paul Sun-
Hyung Lee) works two jobs to further his girl's ambitions, do
triples, deep bends, whirls and whatever else impresses the
bench full of judges who score every second of each skater as
though the sport were a matter of life and death.
For the target audience still in secondary school, "Ice Princess"
subliminally conveys the lesson that you're not either a brainiac
or a jock. It's not just that Casey is an A student in physics: it's
that she has actually set up a computer program, filming her
colleagues and scanning the motion pictures into her computer
to analyze the best ways to perform. For example using
formulas that appear on the screen to be more complicated than
E=MC squared, she calculates just how much extra velocity can
arise when a skater crosses her arms in front of her.
Unfortunately for her social life, she has a tendency to spout
physical laws to a boy at a party who is interested in her,
sending him on his way. It's also surprising that this woman
appears to indulge in her first kiss at the age of seventeen, but if
that's what it takes to get a G rating, so be it.
Rated G. 98 minutes © 2005 by Harvey Karten
harveycritic@cs.com
========== X-RAMR-ID: 39593 X-Language: en X-RT-ReviewID: 1370791 X-RT-TitleID: 10003969 X-RT-SourceID: 570 X-RT-AuthorID: 1123 X-RT-RatingText: B
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews