Ying xiong (2002): ***1/2 out of ****
Directed by Zhang Yimou. Screenplay by Zhang, Li Feng and Wang Bin. Starring
Jet Li, Tony Leung Chiu Wai, Maggie Cheung, Zhang Ziyi, Chen Daoming and Donnie
Yen.
by Andy Keast
Zhang Yimou's 'Ying xiong' is an epic poem of a movie, steeped in Chinese
folklore and cycling it's way through violence, mystery, romance, and tragedy.
It is also an eye-popping and at times stirring martial arts film, inhabiting a
millennia-old genre of timeless popularity, *wu xia.* Several of these films
are produced every year, though every time I see a good one I feel as if I'm
completely new to the genre. A lot of this is due to the directing and the
performances, made by actors who project bold human emotions while portraying
fearless, invincible heroes.
Depending on the history, the film takes place sometime around 220 BC. The
land that will be known as China is divided into warring states and without a
ruler. Mightiest of these states is the massive kingdom of Qin, and the film
is based on a legend of assassins who attempt to kill Qin's leader (Chen Dao
Ming) before their respective kingdoms far under his armies. These assassins
make up almost a who's-who of Chinese and Cantonese film stars: Jet Li, the
stoic Tony Leung Chiu Wai, Maggie Cheung, Donnie Yen, and Zhang Ziyi. The
course of events leading up to the assassins' attempt on the King's life is
recounted by Li and the king in his throne room in about three-and-a-half
different ways. Zhang films each episode in a different color scheme, which
works on both symbolic (red - imagination, blue - perceived reality, white -
truth, green - enlightenment/peace) and base levels (a good device for
audiences to literally keep all the stories straight). If this is sounds all
too familiar, know that this is not the first -nor will it be the last- movie
to 'borrow' from 'Rashômon.'
This has also been the subject of Zhou Xiaowen's 'Qin song' ('The Emperor's
Shadow') and Chen Kaige's 'Jing ke ci qin wang' ('The Emperor and the
Assassin'). All three are romantic visions of history, which I always prefer
over something that tries for the oxymoron that is 'historical accuracy' (how
could one today know with any confidence the events of 2200 years ago?). Give
me a fantasy any day. Ying xiong was directed by Zhang Yimou, whose output in
the 1990s has turned out to be one the best of that decade, including 'Ju Dou,'
'Da hong deng long gao gao gua' ('Raise the Red Lantern'), 'Qiu Ju da guan si'
('The Story of Qiu Ju'), 'Huozhe' ('To Live') and 'Yao a yao yao dao waipo
qiao' ('Shanghai Triad') -I suppose a sign that read *I'm Dating Gong Li* may
have been pushing it.
Zhang's use of color in the film is worthy of a separate review altogether: I
went in knowing that it had been shot by Australia's great Christopher Doyle,
and indeed any review you may read praising 'Ying xiong''s look and design are
true: this man does not mess around. As he has done with the work of Wong Kar
Wai, and recently with Phillip Noyce's 'Rabbit-Proof Fence' and 'The Quiet
American,' he demonstrates his expressionist vision of the world and mastery of
color…and what can I say? It's a beautiful movie.
Ying xiong is also about an enlightenment of sorts that took place in China in
that time, and contains a number of Confucian themes. Zhang's directing is
strong enough so as to balance the swordplay and the philosophy, infusing his
duels with multiple meanings for those who wish to seek them out. Underneath
the main story arc lies the Confucian idea that rulers must rule with
benevolence and for the good of all people, and there's even a line late in the
film: "The highest ideal for a warrior is to ultimately lay down his sword."
This is exemplified in the plight of Broken Sword, played by Tony Leung. He is
my favorite character in the film, and also engages in my favorite duel -one
where he and the king leap around the throne room as gigantic green curtains
swirl and billow all around them. It's during this scene that Leung finally
realizes what must happen in order for them to attain peace in their time.
After the arrival of 'Enter the Dragon' in 1973, martial arts films were for
the most part sought out only by devoted fans of the genre and were otherwise
not taken seriously by audiences in the United States, whose awareness of the
martial arts tradition remains slim (the genre dates back as far as 3rd Century
BC). 2000 saw unprecedented change with the release of Ang Lee's 'Crouching
Tiger, Hidden Dragon' -a movie with what American critics thought of as a
revisionist approach to wu xia, while in the East it was simply another martial
arts film. Between Lee's film, Tarantino's advocacy for Hong Kong cinema, the
'rediscovery' (though in actuality it is just the discovery) of John Woo's
pre-U.S. action films, the success of 'Fa yeung nin wa' and the greater success
of 'Lost in Translation,' the Orient has become the current 'other' of choice
for Americans (is there anyone you know who is specifically not excited for
'2046'?), the transpacific success of their films unfortunately resting upon
their marketability as works of either exotica or exploitation. Whether the
same will happen with 'Ying xiong,' which has been marketed to Americans as a
high-octane action picture, who can say?
au3480@wayne.edu
arthistoryguy@aol.com
========== X-RAMR-ID: 38708 X-Language: en X-RT-ReviewID: 1323657 X-RT-TitleID: 1131781 X-RT-AuthorID: 9883 X-RT-RatingText: 3.5/4
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews