BRIEF ENCOUNTER (1946)
A Film Review Copyright Dragan Antulov 2003
People usually associate David Lean with "larger-than-life" movie spectacles like THE BRIDGE ON THE RIVER KWAI, LAWRENCE OF ARABIA and DOCTOR ZHIVAGO. However, the most beloved of all his films isn't among that group - it is BRIEF ENCOUNTER, relatively cheap, black-and-white and seemingly unattractive 1946 melodrama about most prosaic characters imaginable set in the most prosaic surrounding, so different from the epic exotic locations and epic characters that turned David Lean into one of 20th Century's greatest filmmakers.
The plot is based on the one-act play by Noel Coward, famous English playwright who worked with David Lean on his early films, including this one. Protagonist is Laura Jesson (played by Celia Johnson), typical English middle-class housewife who has two children, dependable but boring husband Frank (played by Cyril Raymond) and life routine that involves stopping at Milford Junction railway station every Thursday afternoon. One of those afternoons she gets piece of coal in her eye and is immediately helped by Doctor Alec Harvey (played by Trevor Howard), general practitioner who just happened to be at the station. Next week Laura again meets Harvey and two of them gradually begin to spend time together - first at the restaurant, than at the movies - until they finally confess feelings to each other. But their romance is quashed even before it actually began, because their families and deeply ingrained sense of duty prevent them from following their heart and doing the unimaginable.
Few films represent the entirety of its maker's talent as BRIEF ENCOUNTER does. In any other hands this film would have been recipe for disaster - hardly anything happens, the end is telegraphed at the very beginning, sets are unappealing and the doomed couple in this film is not played by the actors whom modern audience would be associate with stardom. But Lean manages to overcome those obstacles by employing many interesting film-making techniques and relying on talents of his cast and crew. Black-and-white photography by Robert Krasker and Rachmaninov's Second Piano Concerto create powerful atmosphere, while Celia Johnson and Trevor Howard - people who don't look like they are in the prime of their lives - look quite believable as lovers. Celia Johnson is especially convincing in her role which is quite demanding, since it requires her to play loving mother, woman struck both by schoolgirl-like crush and deep feelings of remorse and despair. Lean also relies on good cast of character actors, especially Stanley Holloway and Joyce Carey in memorable performances of working-class people who have their own, much funnier and healthier romance.
Another ingredient to the story is Lean's introduction of "Flames of Passion" - romantic movie which Harvey and Laura watch in the theatre. That melodrama, glimpsed through the preview, is everything BRIEF ENCOUNTER is not - set in exotic locations, with stars and not particularly good. Ironically, words used in the trailer - "stupendous", "colossal", "gigantic" and "epoch-making" would later become part of vocabulary for any critic describing David Lean's film.
Romance in BRIEF ENCOUNTER is not only different from most other movie romances in its exterior; it is different because it shows real adults with real problems instead of teenagers in adult's costumes. Lovers in this film are faced with terrible dilemma - they recognise their feelings but they are also more than aware of their social responsibilities. On one hand there is short-term bliss followed by risks and uncertainties that people at certain age aren't exactly comfortable with; on the other hand, there is routine and safety, but also the nagging feeling that same passion would never be felt for the rest of life. It isn't surprising that the most loyal audience for this film could be found among older viewers, those with an age and experience similar to the protagonists of this film.
Additional value of BRIEF ENCOUNTER could be found in the way it portrays British (and for that matter, any other European) society sixty or seventy years ago. The moral values of that time might seem quite alien to many of modern viewers, especially those who grew up in post-Cold War era of instant self-gratification. People in this film are divided by invisible social lines; in case of Britain, class is revealed not only through external expressions of material wealth or morals (looser at lower levels of society), but also through language. People who belong to middle class spend incredible amounts of energy in order to keep appearances and adhere to unwritten codes of social conduct, all in the name of imaginary social order. Anything that would destroy such order is strictly prohibited and things like divorce are indistinguishable from scandal; people are conditioned to sacrifice their personal happiness for greater good of the society; recent experience of WW2 only strengthened such sentiments.
Lean, in order to make BRIEF ENCOUNTER as convincing and closer to real life as possible, portrayed the events from the perspective of Laura. This allowed even the modern audience to sympathise with her decision; perhaps Harvey, whom we see only in brief moments, isn't such nice guy after all. Extra and in some ways unnecessary speculations are quashed by Lean's decision to give brief glimpse into the affair from Harvey's perspective, in a brief confrontation with his friend Stephen Lynn. This episode, which the movie could have easily been without, not only tears the otherwise perfect structure of the film, but also leads to all kinds of rather trivial speculations about real nature of Harvey's relation with Lynn. That scene is the reason why BRIEF ENCOUNTER is great film, but not a masterpiece in the same rank with Lean's later works.
RATING: 8/10 (+++)
Review written on August 12th 2003
Dragan Antulov a.k.a. Drax http://film.purger.com - Filmske recenzije na hrvatskom/Movie Reviews in Croatian
========== X-RAMR-ID: 35465 X-Language: en X-RT-ReviewID: 1186517 X-RT-TitleID: 1003094 X-RT-AuthorID: 1307 X-RT-RatingText: 8/10
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews